Birthstone jewelry holds a special place in many people’s hearts. Whether it was given as a birthday gift, a milestone present, or a family keepsake, these pieces often carry sentimental and symbolic value. But when you’re ready to part with birthstone jewelry—whether to downsize your collection or unlock some extra cash—it helps to know the best way to go about it.
At Sell My Jewelry, we specialize in helping people sell all types of jewelry, including pieces featuring birthstones. Here’s everything you need to know to get the most out of your sale.
What Are The Birthstones for Each Month?
Birthstone jewelry is made with gemstones associated with specific months of the year. Each month has its own gem (or in some cases, multiple options), and these stones are often featured in rings, pendants, earrings, and bracelets. Common birthstones include:
- January – Garnet
- February – Amethyst
- March – Aquamarine
- April – Diamond
- May – Emerald
- June – Pearl or Alexandrite
- July – Ruby
- August – Peridot or Spinel
- September – Sapphire
- October – Opal or Tourmaline
- November – Topaz or Citrine
- December – Turquoise, Zircon, or Tanzanite
These gemstones can vary widely in value depending on size, quality, and setting.
Know What You Have
Before you list your birthstone jewelry for sale, it helps to identify a few key details:
- The gemstone type and authenticity – Natural stones tend to fetch higher prices than synthetic or lab-created ones.
- Metal type – Is it set in gold, silver, or platinum? The metal itself adds value.
- Condition – Scratches, chips, or loose settings can affect resale price.
- Designer or brand – Pieces from Tiffany & Co., Cartier, or other known brands may command premium offers.
If you’re not sure how to evaluate your jewelry, the team at Sell My Jewelry can help assess the item and walk you through the process.
Tips to Get a Better Offer
To increase your chances of getting a fair offer, follow these simple tips:
- Clean the piece – A quick polish can make stones sparkle and improve presentation.
- Take clear photos – If you’re submitting pictures online, use natural lighting and focus on close-up shots.
- Gather paperwork – If you have a receipt, original box, or certificate of authenticity, include it.
- Know the market – Birthstones like diamonds, sapphires, rubies, and emeralds tend to retain higher value compared to softer stones like opals or pearls.
Selling Sentimental Pieces
It can be emotional to let go of birthstone jewelry, especially if it was a meaningful gift. If you’re on the fence, consider which pieces you truly wear or treasure—and which ones are sitting in a drawer. Selling can be a practical way to give your jewelry new life while freeing up space and funds for something new.
Sell Birthstone Jewelry with Confidence | Sell My Jewelry
At Sell My Jewelry, we’ve helped thousands of people sell everything from diamond engagement rings to vintage amethyst pendants. Our process is quick, secure, and tailored to your needs. We offer free online jewelry appraisal kits. Whether your piece is brand new or passed down through generations, we’ll help you understand its value and guide you every step of the way.